RE: Shuffields in BFL - I believe that weekend anglers' egos get in the way of their common sense. The Shuffields fish for a living. When a man is a professional, at whatever sport, and dedicates all of his work time to that sport, he is going to beat any other player in that sport who participates part time.
I offer you this example: This past weekend, I fished the BFL on Lake Norman as a co-angler. The boater I drew, which was the typical boater, pre-fished the Saturday before the tournament, and then pre-fished on Thursday afternoon before the tournament. The rest of the week he is employed, just like most other BFL competitors. A day and half of pre-fishing is not enough practice to compete with a professinal angler who can dedicate several days before a tournament to that tournament, as fishing is the professional's livelihood.
In my opinion, the BFL and Weekend Series are aimed at the weekend angler – the guy who is employed and practices as much as he can, then fishes the tournament. It is not intended, in my opinion, for the guy who is a professional and spends all week prepping for a one-day derby against a bunch of weekend guys.
Time on the water equals success. If you spend 1 day in practice for a tournament and the Shuffieds spend 4 days, you will lose. It's as simple as that.
If you are competing against a man who has triple the time on the water in prepping for a one-day tournament, you are simply donating your $200 to him.
It may be that a weekend angler figures its worth $200 bucks for a weekend guy to say he fished against a professional in a tournament. Maybe the weekend guy wants to boast that he came close to beating the pro, or at least came within "X" number of pounds. For that scenario, the weekend guy would have to evaluate that value on an individual basis.
If you're not star-struck regarding fishing against a professional, and fishing against a professional in a weekend tournament has no monetary value to you, do you honestly feel the playing field is level? Does your wallet feel that the playing field is level?
Let your wallet be your guide.